Jump to Navigation

The Supreme Court defines the meaning of arthritis in Hopkins

Injured workers call into our office frequently with questions about their "combined condition" denial. A combined condition denial is often confusing for injured workers, who have their workers' compensation benefits suddenly cut off because insurance companies decide that the major cause of their condition is no longer (or never was) an otherwise compensable injury, but instead caused in major part by a "preexisting condition." The recent Oregon Supreme Court decision in Hopkins v. SAIF, 349 OR 348 (December 9, 2010), may have made things that much tougher for injured workers by concluding that the legislature did not limit the term "arthritis" to a particular form of "arthritis."

In Hopkins, the Supreme Court held that, in defining a "preexisting condition," the legislature intended the term "arthritis" to mean the inflammation of one or more joints, due to infectious, metabolic, or constitutional causes, and resulting in breakdown, degeneration, or structural change. In reaching this conclusion, the Supreme Court disagreed with claimant's argument that "arthritis" should be limited to inflammation of moveable (or "freely articulating") joints. With this definition of arthritis, the Supreme Court went on to affirm the Board's conclusion that Ms. Hopkins had preexisting arthritis.

If you are an injured worker and have received a denial, whether it is for a combined condition or otherwise, please call Martin L. Alvey P.C. to discuss your claim.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Contact Us

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.

Subscribe to This Blog's Feed Visit Our Website FindLaw Network
Office Locations

Alvey Law Group
10 Pier One
Astoria, OR 97103

Phone: 503-928-3848
Toll Free: 866-509-3516
Fax: 503-229-1094
Get Directions

Alvey Law Group
8555 SW Apple Way
Portland, OR 97225

Phone: 503-325-5509
Toll Free: 866-509-3516
Get Directions